🔗 Share this article

Brentford offer a compelling case study of the outcome when a well-run club loses its long-term manager and key players. Can the processes that drove the club so far withstand such transition? Can a much-admired data-driven scouting system find suitable new talent? Hiring a head coach with limited top-level background, Keith Andrews, additionally challenges the strength of the club's structure.

Varied Signals but Encouraging Trends

The signs thus far are mixed but optimistic overall. While highly regarded as Thomas Frank is in Brentford legacy, his exit to join Tottenham highlighted that development was never straightforward or a consistently rising trajectory. The team with a reported salary expenditure of £50m a year, one of the lowest in the Premier League, has heavy tides to overcome. The previous campaign's tenth position was coupled with disappointment in missing out on continental competition indicates how far expectations had risen.

Testing Times and Significant Victories

This weekend, Manchester City visit a side starting in the relative safety of thirteenth position, despite fluctuations from losing 3-1 at Craven Cottage a two weeks ago to a well-earned 3-1 at their ground defeat of Manchester United recently. With the caveat that several consider United a soft touch, and one of Frank’s last games was a four-three defeat of the Portuguese manager's squad, beating them nonetheless held significance for the new head coach. No club have defeated both Manchester clubs in consecutive fixtures since Spurs in the mid-nineties.

Familiar Face in a Fresh Role

Andrews was no stranger to Brentford. Last season, he patrolled the technical area as Frank’s dead-ball expert. Ipswich’s Kieran McKenna, Bodø/Glimt’s Kjetil Knutsen and Danny Röhl were considered. The most probable in-house option was assistant coach Justin Cochrane, but he followed the ex-manager to Tottenham.

Changes Both On and Off the Field

The off-season was a period of transformation on and off the pitch. The owner, whose analytics approach follows his success in the gambling sphere, sold a stake to former a company chief executive and Labour party supporter Gary Lubner and the director a Hollywood figure, with his wife, Claudia Schiffer, has been attracting media attention to the directors’ box.

Stability and Leadership

The stability at the club is maintained by the chief executive, and Phil Giles. Giles, who has been at the club for a decade, spoke publicly last week, where he admitted Brentford can not rest on laurels with the leadership patting itself on the back for jobs well done. “There is no such thing as established,” he said. “It’s not even a football word. At what point are we established? Probably never. For a club of our stature, it's unlikely you can ever become comfortable.”

Rebuilding and Fresh Talent

Brentford started versus United in seventeenth position, the survival spot. Losing Frank, and key stars such as the forwards Bryan Mbeumo and Yoane Wissa, the engine-room and skipper Christian Nørgaard along with shot-stopper the Dutchman, looked like a squad's core was being ripped out. The owner, the CEO and Giles had a strategy; the new boss took over ability to work with. Igor Thiago was at the team, the previous summer’s big signing lost to the former coach through injury. The forward's quartet of strikes from 10 shots have come at the best efficiency of every Premier League player so far.

Squad Strengths and Tools

Rapid Kevin Schade was established in the attack; he combined with the forward and the winger in netting ten or more goals in the previous campaign. The experienced midfielder brings elite experience in the center of the park where stats indicate Yehor Yarmolyuk, 21, as among the leading defensive workers in the Premier League. The Ukrainian can pick a pass, as well. Mikkel Damsgaard's unorthodox gait belies real creativity and Michael Kayode is a marauding back who delivers the long throws that are vital part of the arsenal. The goalkeeper, who produced a spot-kick stop from United’s Bruno Fernandes, is enjoying being a first-choice keeper and Dango Ouattara, Mbeumo’s successor on the right, netted the winner versus Aston Villa in August that earned the manager's maiden home win.

Style and Philosophy

With the new boss, Brentford continue to be high-tempo, flinty, awkward to face. Although a slightly reserved publicly than his predecessor, the head coach – a former broadcaster on the Irish Newstalk network who previously held a lengthy position as one of the broadcaster's Championship pundits – handles the media game well. Following his side snatched a draw from Chelsea following a the forward's long throw that created chaos, he considered the dead-ball expertise, and the “carnage” it creates, that is now part of most teams’ makeup. “I felt there’s a little bit of snobbery in the game regarding scenarios like that, but if the big boys do it then it seems to be tolerated,” Andrews said.

Motivational Personalities and Scrutiny

Andrews has attempted to refresh the squad by bringing in two Irish sporting icons, the rugby union player the former captain and successful golf captain the golfer, to address to his team. Not everyone in his homeland is willing on the nation's first top-flight coach since Chris Hughton. Andrews criticised the national team management of the former manager and Roy Keane during his media career. The former boss has been scathing; the pundit a somewhat diplomatic towards someone he confronted aggressively in recent years. “I’ve heard a number of bullshitters over the last decade and Keith Andrews is among them with the top ones,” were the pundit's comments. Andrews taking on the Brentford task is the truest test of those claims and the strength of his club’s structures.